Reference · Coating tests
Cross hatch adhesion test for coated aluminum.
A cross hatch adhesion test cuts through a paint film to the metal, presses pressure-sensitive tape over the cuts, pulls it off and rates how much coating came away. ASTM D3359 describes two versions: an X-cut for thicker films and a lattice of cuts for thinner ones, and the standard ties the choice of method to film thickness. This page covers both methods, how film thickness is measured and what the rating can and cannot tell you.
- Tape test on cut coating
- Method chosen by film thickness
- Rated against a classification scale
What is a cross hatch adhesion test?
Adhesion is how well a paint system holds to the metal and how well its coats hold to each other. The cross hatch test, also called a cross-cut or tape test, checks this on a flat, cured panel. Cutting through the film creates edges where weak adhesion shows: when the tape comes off, poorly bonded coating lifts with it.
It needs only a cutting tool, the specified tape and good light or a magnifier, so it is used for production checks as well as for qualifying a coating system. It is a qualitative test. It rates the amount of coating removed against a scale; it does not measure the force needed to pull the coating off.
ASTM D3359 Method A and Method B
ASTM D3359 is titled "Rating Adhesion by Tape Test". It contains two methods, and the standard ties the choice of method to film thickness.
| Method | Intended for | Cut pattern |
|---|---|---|
| Method A (X-cut) | Primarily coatings thicker than 125 micrometers (5 mils) | An X-cut through the film to the metal |
| Method B (cross-cut lattice) | Coatings thinner than 125 micrometers (5 mils) | A lattice of parallel cuts in two directions, crossing each other |
In both methods the cuts go through the coating to the metal. Tape is laid over the cut area, pressed down firmly and then pulled off in one quick, steady motion. The cut area is examined and compared with the descriptions in the standard's classification scale, which runs from no coating removed to large areas removed.
A rating is only useful together with its method letter. Method A and Method B ratings come from different cut patterns and are not interchangeable.
How is the method tied to film thickness?
The first step is to measure the dry film thickness of the panel under test, not to assume it. For coil coated aluminum, the choice of method follows that measured thickness, and the report should state both the measured value and the method letter it led to.
How is dry film thickness measured?
Dry film thickness is measured with a nondestructive gauge on the cured panel. ASTM D7091 covers nondestructive dry film thickness measurement on metal substrates, and EN 13523-1 is the coil coating method for film thickness. Aluminum is not magnetic, so gauges for it work on the eddy current principle. The gauge is checked against reference standards before use, and several readings are taken across the panel, because film thickness is not perfectly uniform.
A gauge on aluminum reads the total coating above the metal, primer and topcoat together. That total is the film thickness the choice between Method A and Method B is tied to.
What are the limits of the tape test?
- Tape. The method specifies the tape. A different tape, or a different batch of the same tape, can give a different result, so the tape used should be recorded.
- Operator. Cut depth and spacing, how hard the tape is pressed down, and the angle and speed of removal all vary by hand.
- Cutting tool. A dull blade tears the film rather than cutting it, which can loosen coating at the cut edges and lower the rating.
- Cure and conditioning. A film tested before it is fully cured, or straight after a change in temperature or humidity, can rate differently from the same film later.
- What it covers. The test is run on flat panels as made. Adhesion after forming is checked another way, for example with tape on a T-bend, and adhesion after exposure means testing after exposure.
Because of these factors, small rating differences between labs say little unless the tape, the tool and the panel conditioning were the same.
How to specify the test and read the result
- Name the method. State ASTM D3359 with the method letter, or the method the specification names.
- Record the film thickness. The measured dry film thickness belongs in the report, next to the method letter.
- Keep the setup fixed. Compare results only with the same tape, cutting tool and panel conditioning.
- Take the acceptance level from the specification. The required rating comes from the coating specification or the purchase agreement.
For Orbit's prepainted aluminum coil, test reports for a given coating system and color are available on request; state both, and the tests you need, with your RFQ. Surface hardness is a separate property, and the pencil hardness test page explains how it is checked.
Standards referenced
- ASTM D3359, Rating Adhesion by Tape Test
- ASTM D7091, nondestructive measurement of dry film thickness on metal substrates
- EN 13523-1, coil coating test methods, film thickness
- ASTM D4145, Coating Flexibility of Prepainted Sheet (T-bend)
Adhesion test questions.
What is the difference between ASTM D3359 Method A and Method B?
Method A uses an X-cut and is intended primarily for films thicker than 125 micrometers (5 mils). Method B uses a lattice of crossing cuts and is intended for thinner films. Ratings from the two are not interchangeable.
Which method applies to coil coated aluminum?
The method follows the measured dry film thickness of the panel tested. Measure the total film first, then choose Method A or Method B, and state both in the report.
Does the type of tape matter?
Yes. The method specifies the tape, and a different tape or tape batch can change the rating. The tape used should be recorded so results can be compared.
Does a good rating mean the coating will never peel?
No. The test rates adhesion on a flat panel as made. Adhesion after forming or after outdoor exposure needs its own checks.
Can Orbit provide adhesion test reports?
Test reports for a given coating system and color are available on request; state both, and the tests you need, with your RFQ.
Need test data for a coating system?
Send the coating system, color, alloy, thickness, width, quantity and destination, and say which test reports you need. We respond to RFQs within one business day.
