Reference · Coating tests
Pencil hardness test for coated aluminum.
A pencil hardness test pushes pencils of increasing hardness across a cured paint film and reports the hardest pencil that does not damage it. ASTM D3363 describes the method. On coated aluminum coil it is a quick check of how well the surface resists scratching and gouging during handling, forming and installation. It is simple to run and sensitive to how it is run, so this page covers the method, what the result indicates and where it stops.
- Scratch and gouge resistance of the film
- Graded pencils, soft to hard
- Comparative within one test setup
What is a pencil hardness test?
The pencil hardness test ranks the surface hardness of a coating against a set of graded drawing pencils. Pencil leads are made in steps from soft (the B grades) to hard (the H grades). A coating that resists a harder lead without being damaged has the harder surface in this test. Because the scale is a series of steps rather than a measured quantity, the result is a pencil grade, not a number with units.
The test needs little equipment and takes minutes, which is why it turns up on coating datasheets and in batch quality checks. That simplicity also limits what it can tell you.
How does ASTM D3363 work?
ASTM D3363 is titled "Film Hardness by Pencil Test". In general terms the method runs like this:
- The coated panel lies on a firm, level surface.
- Each pencil is prepared the same way: the wood is cut back to expose the lead, and the tip is squared off flat on abrasive paper so it presents a sharp edge.
- The pencil is held at a fixed angle and pushed across the film with firm, even pressure.
- Working through the grades, the operator finds the hardest pencil that does not damage the film.
- The result is reported as the hardest pencil that does not cut into (gouge) the film. ASTM D3363 also defines a scratch hardness, the hardest pencil that does not scratch the film, so the specification should say which one is reported.
What counts as damage, for example a visible scratch mark or only a cut into the film, is set by the specification or agreed between buyer and seller, and the report should say which criterion was used.
The EN 13523 series of coil coating test methods also has a pencil hardness part. Where a European specification calls for it, the report should name that method rather than ASTM D3363, since the two are separate documents.
What does a pencil hardness result indicate?
On coated coil, the grade is read in three ways:
- Resistance to marking. Sheet and coil touch rollers, tools, guides and other sheets during slitting, forming and installation. A harder surface in this test is less likely to be scratched by that contact.
- Cure. An undercured film can be softer than the same film fully cured, so a drop in grade between batches of one system can point to a cure problem worth checking with other tests.
- Consistency. With the same system, the same pencils and the same operator, the grade is a simple batch to batch comparison.
It does not indicate adhesion to the metal, flexibility in forming, resistance to repeated abrasion, or weathering. A harder film is not automatically a better one. On coil that is formed after painting, a formulation change that raises hardness can reduce flexibility, so pencil hardness is read together with a bend test such as the T-bend. Adhesion is a separate property, covered on the cross hatch adhesion test page.
What are the limits of the pencil test?
The method is standardized, but much of it is done by hand, and several factors move the result:
| Factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Operator | Pressure, angle and speed vary between people, and between tests by the same person, unless a mechanical holder is used |
| Pencil brand | Grade letters are not uniform across makers, so the same grade from two brands can differ in hardness |
| Lead preparation | A rounded or chipped tip behaves differently from a freshly squared one |
| Reading the damage | Deciding whether a mark is a scratch, a dent or a cut is a judgement |
| Panel condition | Cure, film thickness and conditioning before the test all affect how the film responds |
Because of these factors, two labs can grade the same panel differently. Results compare well within one lab, one operator and one set of pencils. Across labs, treat small differences with caution.
How to specify and read pencil hardness on coated coil
- Name the method. State ASTM D3363 or the EN 13523 part for pencil hardness, and the damage criterion.
- Test real panels. Panels cut from production or trial coil carry the actual pretreatment, primer, topcoat and cure.
- Keep the setup fixed. Compare results only when the same pencil brand and set, and ideally the same lab, were used.
- Take the grade from the specification. The required grade belongs in the coating specification for the system and use, or in the purchase agreement.
For Orbit's prepainted aluminum coil, test reports for a given coating system and color are available on request; state both, and the tests you need, with your RFQ.
Standards referenced
- ASTM D3363, Film Hardness by Pencil Test
- EN 13523 series, coil coating test methods (pencil hardness part)
- ASTM D4145, Coating Flexibility of Prepainted Sheet (T-bend)
Pencil hardness questions.
What does a pencil hardness test measure?
It ranks how well a cured coating resists scratching and gouging, reported as the hardest pencil in a graded set that does not damage the film. It does not measure adhesion, flexibility or weathering.
What pencil hardness should a coil coating have?
There is no single value. The required grade comes from the coating specification for the system and use, or is agreed between buyer and seller.
Why do two labs get different pencil hardness results?
The test is done largely by hand. Operator pressure and angle, pencil brand, how the lead is prepared and how the damage is judged all vary, so results compare best within one lab and one set of pencils.
Is a harder coating always better?
No. On coil that is formed after painting, a change that raises hardness can reduce flexibility. Pencil hardness is read together with a bend test and an adhesion test.
Can Orbit provide pencil hardness results?
Test reports for a given coating system and color are available on request; state both, and the tests you need, with your RFQ.
Need test data for a coating system?
Send the coating system, color, alloy, thickness, width, quantity and destination, and say which test reports you need. We respond to RFQs within one business day.
