Reference · Coating tests
Delta E explained: color difference for coated coil.
Delta E is a single number that says how far one measured color is from another in a color space. On painted coil it is used to state how close a production run is to the approved color standard. A Delta E figure only means something when the formula, the measuring conditions and the reference standard are stated with it, and this page explains each of those.
- CIELAB color space
- CIE76, CIE94, CIEDE2000
- Tolerances per ASTM D2244
What is Delta E?
The Greek letter delta stands for a difference. A spectrophotometer or colorimeter measures a color and expresses it as coordinates. Measure the approved standard and the production sample the same way, and Delta E is the size of the gap between the two sets of coordinates. Zero means the instrument sees no difference. A larger number means a larger difference.
What Delta E does not tell you on its own is the direction of the difference. A sample can be lighter, darker, redder, greener, yellower or bluer than the standard and give the same total. That is why a useful color report shows the component differences as well as the total.
CIELAB: the L*, a* and b* coordinates
The color difference formulas on this page all start from CIELAB, the CIE 1976 L*a*b* color space. It places every color on three axes:
| Coordinate | Axis | A positive difference (sample minus standard) means |
|---|---|---|
| L* | Lightness, from black to white | The sample is lighter |
| a* | Green (minus) to red (plus) | The sample is redder (negative: greener) |
| b* | Blue (minus) to yellow (plus) | The sample is yellower (negative: bluer) |
The same coordinates can be expressed as lightness, chroma and hue, written L*, C* and h. Chroma describes how saturated a color is and hue describes which color it is. The later Delta E formulas work in these terms because the eye judges differences in chroma and hue differently from differences in lightness.
CIE76 vs CIE94 vs CIEDE2000
CIELAB is not perceptually even. A given distance between two points looks like a bigger difference in some parts of the color space than in others. Each newer formula corrects more of that, so the number follows what an observer sees more closely.
| Formula | Published as | What it does | What it changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| CIE76 (Delta E*ab) | CIE 1976 L*a*b* color difference | Straight-line distance between the two points in CIELAB | The starting point: no weighting, so equal numbers do not always look equal |
| CIE94 (Delta E*94) | CIE 116-1995 | Splits the difference into lightness, chroma and hue and weights each | Adds weighting for chroma and hue, so the same numeric difference counts for less in strongly saturated colors |
| CIEDE2000 (Delta E00) | CIE 142:2001, standardized as CIE S 014-6:2013 | Keeps the lightness, chroma and hue split and adds further corrections | Adds a hue rotation term for the blue region and compensation for neutral colors and for lightness |
The practical consequence: the same pair of panels gives different Delta E values under different formulas. A tolerance written as a bare number, with no formula named, cannot be checked consistently, because supplier and customer may be calculating different things.
ASTM D2244 and who sets the tolerance
ASTM D2244 is the practice for calculating color tolerances and color differences from instrumentally measured color coordinates. It covers several color-difference formulas, including CIELAB, CMC, CIE94, DIN99o and CIEDE2000. It does not hand down a single acceptable Delta E for every product. D2244 provides for the buyer and the seller to agree on the tolerance and the calculation method to be used.
That makes the color tolerance a contract term, not a property of the paint.
How a color tolerance is written for painted coil
A usable color Delta E tolerance states more than the number. It should name:
- The formula. CIE76, CIE94, CIEDE2000 or another method from D2244, named in full.
- The illuminant and standard observer. The light source and observer the coordinates are calculated for. Two samples are metameric when they match under one light source or observer but not another.
- The instrument geometry. Sphere or directional geometry, and for a sphere instrument whether the specular component is included or excluded. Readings from a sphere instrument and a 45/0 instrument are taken in different geometries; compare values only from the same geometry and settings.
- The reference standard. Which physical panel or agreed coordinates the run is measured against.
- Total or by component. Whether the limit applies to the total Delta E only, or also to the lightness (L*), green-red (a*) and blue-yellow (b*) differences separately.
This page deliberately gives no typical tolerance values. The right figure depends on the color, the finish, the formula and the use, and it is set between buyer and seller. For how a target color is chosen in the first place, from a RAL reference or a customer sample, see RAL versus custom color matching.
Gloss, texture and effect finishes
D2244 notes that gloss and texture can affect how well instrument values agree with visual acceptance. Two panels can measure close in color and still look different side by side if one is glossier or has a different surface texture, and the reverse can happen too. For that reason gloss is specified and measured as a separate property from color.
The same caution applies with more force to effect finishes. Metallic and similar finishes change appearance with viewing angle, which a single-angle color measurement does not fully capture, and textured, brushed or woodgrain surfaces scatter light differently from a smooth solid color. For these, visual approval against the physical standard carries more weight. The finishes Orbit offers are listed on the finishes overview.
Batch-to-batch color control
On a coil line, color control is a comparison against a fixed reference, run after run:
- A master standard. One approved physical panel, with its measured coordinates on record, is the reference for every later batch. Standards should be stored away from light and handling, since they can change over time.
- Measure each run against it. Each production run is measured under the agreed conditions and the Delta E is calculated against the master, not against the previous run, so small differences do not add up from batch to batch. Two lots can still differ from each other by up to about twice the tolerance, so for panels that sit side by side, ask for lot-to-lot limits or supply from a single lot.
- Approve on a physical sample. Numbers support the decision, but the final approval is made on a physical panel viewed beside the standard, especially for effect finishes.
Orbit offers RAL or custom color matching on prepainted aluminum coil, typically 6 MT per color, with an MOQ of 6.5 MT. Corrosion performance, a separate question from color match, is covered on the salt spray test reference.
Standards referenced
- ASTM D2244, practice for calculating color tolerances and color differences from instrumentally measured color coordinates
- CIE 015:2018, Colorimetry, 4th Edition, the CIE recommendations on colorimetry, including color space coordinates and color differences
- CIE 116-1995, Industrial colour-difference evaluation, the basis of the CIE94 formula
- CIE 142:2001, Improvement to industrial colour-difference evaluation, the basis of the CIEDE2000 formula, standardized as CIE S 014-6:2013
Delta E questions.
What does Delta E mean?
Delta E is a single number for how far one measured color is from another in a color space, usually CIELAB. Zero means no measured difference, and a larger number means a larger difference.
What is a good Delta E for painted coil?
There is no single figure. ASTM D2244 provides for the buyer and seller to agree the tolerance and the calculation method, and the right value depends on the color, finish, formula and use.
What is the difference between CIE76 and CIEDE2000?
CIE76 is the straight-line distance between two colors in CIELAB. CIEDE2000 splits the difference into lightness, chroma and hue and applies corrections so the number follows visual perception more closely. The same pair of samples gives different values under each.
What do L*, a* and b* mean?
L* is lightness from black to white, a* runs from green (minus) to red (plus) and b* from blue (minus) to yellow (plus). A color difference report shows the change in each as well as the total Delta E.
Why can two panels with a low Delta E still look different?
Gloss and surface texture affect how a color looks, and ASTM D2244 notes they can affect how well instrument values match visual judgment. Metallic finishes also change with viewing angle, which a single-angle measurement does not fully capture.
What should a color tolerance on a purchase order include?
The Delta E formula, the illuminant and observer, the instrument geometry, the reference standard and whether the limit applies to the total or to each component.
Have a color to match?
Send the RAL code or a physical sample, the coating system, finish, color tolerance, thickness, width, quantity and destination. We respond to RFQs within one business day.
