Aluminum vs Galvanized Steel Coil: Weight, Corrosion, Cost.

Aluminum vs galvanized steel comes down to weight, corrosion behavior, stiffness and cost per finished part. Aluminum is roughly a third the density of steel and does not rust; galvanized steel is stiffer at the same thickness and relies on its zinc coating to keep the steel underneath from rusting. Which one fits depends on the product, the exposure and how cost is measured.

Key takeaways

  • Using typical densities of 2.70 g/cm³ for aluminum and 7.85 g/cm³ for steel, aluminum sheet weighs roughly a third as much as steel sheet of the same size and thickness.
  • Aluminum protects itself with a thin oxide film. Galvanized steel is protected by zinc, which is consumed over time, and the steel rusts where the zinc is gone.
  • Steel is stiffer at the same thickness, so an aluminum part may need to be thicker, which narrows the weight gap.
  • Compare cost per part or per square meter, not per tonne.

Aluminum vs galvanized steel: how big is the weight difference?

A typical density for aluminum is 2.70 g/cm³, and the conventional design value for steel is 7.85 g/cm³. Dividing one by the other gives about 0.34, so at the same size and thickness aluminum sheet weighs roughly a third as much as steel. The zinc coating on galvanized sheet adds a little to the steel figure.

Plain arithmetic from typical densities. Coating weight ignored.
BasisAluminum (2.70 g/cm³)Steel (7.85 g/cm³)
Mass of 1 m² at 1.0 mm2.70 kg7.85 kg
Area in 1 tonne at 1.0 mmAbout 370 m²About 127 m²

The ratio holds only at equal thickness. Steel is stiffer than aluminum, so a panel that has to resist the same deflection or the same dent may be specified thicker in aluminum. The weight saving on a finished part is therefore usually smaller than the density ratio alone suggests, and it has to be worked out for the actual part.

How does each metal resist corrosion?

Aluminum forms a thin natural oxide film that protects it in near-neutral conditions, such as most outdoor air and rainwater. Strong acids and strong alkalis attack that film. Aluminum does not rust, because rust is iron oxide, but it can corrode under the wrong conditions, including wet contact with more noble metals such as steel, stainless steel or copper.

Galvanized steel is protected by its zinc coating. Zinc corrodes in place of the steel, including at small scratches and cut edges, which is why galvanized sheet tolerates minor coating damage. The zinc is consumed as it does this, so once it is used up locally, the steel underneath starts to rust. How long that takes depends on the coating weight and the exposure.

Both metals are often painted, and a coil-coated finish shifts the comparison to what happens at cut edges and scratches. A painted aluminum edge exposes aluminum; a painted galvanized edge exposes steel protected by a thin band of zinc. Our page on corrosion of aluminum and how to prevent it covers the types to design against, including contact with steel.

What drives the cost difference?

The two metals are priced per tonne, but per-tonne price is the wrong basis for most sheet products. Buyers use metal by area and thickness, and a tonne of aluminum covers close to three times the area of a tonne of steel at the same thickness. The cost drivers to compare are:

  • Thickness needed. If stiffness or dent resistance forces a thicker aluminum gauge, some of the area advantage goes.
  • Coating. The paint system can be the same on both, but the extra protection a steel part needs at edges and in harsh exposures can add cost.
  • Freight and handling. Lighter parts cost less to move and install, which matters more for some products than others.
  • Service life and maintenance. Repainting or replacing a rusted part has a cost that a per-tonne comparison leaves out.
  • Scrap and offcuts. Offcut and end-of-life value differ between the metals.

No single price comparison holds for every product. Cost the actual part, in the actual thickness, with its coating and freight.

How do they compare in forming?

Both metals are formed on the same kinds of equipment: roll formers, press brakes and folders. Formability in aluminum depends on alloy, temper and thickness. Softer tempers bend tighter, and harder tempers carry more strength but need larger bend radii. Galvanized steel forming depends on steel grade and thickness, and the zinc coating has to survive the bend too.

The two metals differ in stiffness and springback, so tooling and settings that suit one may need adjustment for the other. A trial on the actual profile is the reliable check.

Which products suit each substrate?

  • Aluminum suits products where weight, freedom from red rust or coastal exposure weigh heavily: gutters, cladding, roofing in corrosive sites, signage, truck and trailer panels and rolling shutters.
  • Galvanized steel suits products where stiffness at low thickness and material cost per part weigh heavily, and where the exposure and detailing let the zinc coating do its job.

Many product ranges use both. The choice for a given part follows its exposure, its stiffness requirement and the total cost.

Where does Orbit fit?

Orbit makes aluminum coil in 1xxx, 3xxx and 5xxx alloys, 0.20 to 2.00 mm thick and up to 1650 mm wide, mill finish or coated, with 3105 as the main coated substrate. Orbit also sells coated steel coil; steel substrate details are confirmed per RFQ.

Common questions

How much lighter is aluminum than galvanized steel?

Using typical densities of 2.70 g/cm³ for aluminum and 7.85 g/cm³ for steel, aluminum weighs roughly a third as much at the same size and thickness. An aluminum part may need to be thicker for stiffness, which narrows the difference.

Does aluminum rust like steel?

No. Rust is iron oxide. Aluminum forms a thin oxide film that protects it in near-neutral conditions, but it can corrode in strong acids or alkalis or in wet contact with more noble metals.

Is aluminum more expensive than galvanized steel?

It depends on the basis. A per-tonne comparison misleads, because a tonne of aluminum covers close to three times the area of a tonne of steel at the same thickness. Compare the cost of the finished part, with thickness, coating, freight and service life included.

Can aluminum touch galvanized steel?

Contact between aluminum and galvanized steel is generally less of a concern than contact with bare steel while the zinc is intact. Where the zinc is worn away and the area stays wet, the exposed steel can speed up corrosion of the aluminum, so keep joints dry or separate the metals.

Is aluminum harder to form than galvanized steel?

Not in general. It depends on alloy, temper and thickness for aluminum and on grade and thickness for steel. The two differ in springback, so trial the actual profile.

References

  • Densities: 2.70 g/cm³ is a typical value for aluminum and 7.85 g/cm³ the conventional design value for steel. Both are used here as stated values for plain arithmetic, not as specification limits.
  • Orbit Aluminum Industries: aluminum corrosion resource page, for the oxide film and galvanic contact.
  • Orbit Aluminum Industries: rolled aluminum coil and prepainted steel coil product pages.
Orbit is an integrated aluminum coil manufacturer in Aqaba, Jordan, family owned and operating since 1976, with recycling, casting, rolling and coil coating. We hold ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001.

Choosing a coil substrate?

Send the product, exposure, gauge, width, coating system and color. We respond to RFQs within one business day.

Request a Quote

The technical information in this article is prepared in good faith and verified against publicly available industry sources at the time of writing. Product specifications, applications and requirements can vary by project; always confirm current specifications directly with Orbit Aluminum Industries before purchasing or specifying. Orbit Aluminum Industries is not liable for decisions made or outcomes resulting from use of this content. See our Terms & Conditions.